Joshua, Judah and I went to see 'The Golden Compass" today. This movie, starring Dakota Blue Richards, Nicole Kidman, and Sam Elliott (among others), has drawn a lot of criticism from Christians around the world, and particularly the Roman Catholic Church.
Not surprising, really. The movie is made after the trilogy His Dark Materials by author Philip Pullmann. A trilogy, you ask? Yes, a trilogy. Much like Lord of the Rings, with good and bad and war and magic and amazing creatures, amazing scenery and amazing animated creatures. But unlike Tolkien's Lord of the Ring trilogy, this trilogy sets out to reveal the evil of the church and the evil of Christianity. Pullman is very, very clear in his agenda to show the church to be nothing but an evil institution, and the Christian faith nothing but a farce.
And so The Golden Compass is a about the evil the Magisterium (the institutional church) seeks to do the minds of little innocent children: they seek to seperate them from their personalities. In the magical world where this story takes place, these personalities reside outside a person, in the shape of an animal, and they are called Deamons. The whole purpose of the story, as will become clearer in the next two episiodes, is to demonstrate that mankind should leave God and the church behind. In the story, God is an old and tired lying angel, who ends up dying.
I am troubled by this move. I don't know if it was wise to see this movie with my kids. Why do it? My kids are going to see this movie, if not with me, than somewhere else. I'd rather have the conversation about the movie with them!
To be sire, I don't believe in the God that Pullman creates in his st6ory either.And I would hate the magisterium just as much. If the role of the church is to seperate you from your personality, to control your thinking, to limit your freedom and to hang on to its power, than I would hate it to...
And there is the rub. Pullman seems to fight a church that seeks to control and dominate and harm and destroy. I am deeply, deeply sorry to have to say that he has historic cause for that. But the God I believe him wants nothing of the kind. He comes, as a little baby, into a dark world and teaches man to forgive, serve, embrace, release, give and redeem. He encourages people to think, and seeks to set them free. How unfortunate that Pullman - and so many with him - have come to see the church as the exact opposite. There's a conversation I'd like to have with my boys.
Which leaves the deamons. In the spiritual world in which we live I am afraid demons are nothing to be toyed with. But in the make-believe world of Pullman they are an elegant way of showing the true character of a person. Maybe that's another interesting conversation to have with them: what animal best resembles the person you want to be.
Verdict: go see that movie -- but if you see it with your kids, have (a talk) or two about it!
Some reviews said the movie felt rushed. But I liked it a lot. Great scenery, great graphics. The Polar bear is amazing. The acting is OK. Nicole Kidman needed an extra layer of make-up, I thought. I like Sam Elliott in anything he does (RoadHouse!)
Recent Comments